The approach.
How do hiking boots fare on snow?
Barely adequately, it seems.
We were plodding up a boulder-speckled snowfield on the approach to Lincoln Falls. I had chosen to do as my two climbing partners and go crampon-commando. But the fundamental difference between me and them was that I was in hiking boots, and them, the serious, hard-core footwear that meant business on mountains: mountaineering boots. Ice climbing and mountaineering gear had unfortunately been pushed to the back of the expenses pecking order, behind an imminent trip to Ireland (jaunts in Europe without fail require copious amount of money) and a climbing rope (a not-in-the-strict-sense essential, but for someone at my ability level and clear tendency for clumsiness, absolutely vital). So I was stuck with what I had, which, while impressively water-resistant, were clearly not—judging by their clear susceptibility to the combined effects of gravity and snow—intended for much of anything but dry dirt and rock.
Which was obviously not what we were dealing with here.
Lincoln Falls on the center-left, Mt. Lincoln (elev. 14,293 ft) on the far right.
After we had returned from our adventure, I was surprised and delighted to learn that the frozen waterfalls we had climbed up lay by the looks of it around two thousand feet below the summit of a fourteener by the name of Mt. Lincoln (‘fourteener’ is an appellation assigned to mountains exceeding 14,000 feet in height—Colorado boasts 54 of these beauties) A real fourteener!
Which meant that we were hiking at about 12,000 feet, which accounted for the snow-draped landscape and the wild look about the place. And the tree line we crossed on our ascent. And my labored gasping, which, while nothing new as I’m out of shape and very much aware of this, I’m okay with at 12,000 feet. That’s higher than some mountains after all.
The first pitch.
When we reached the base of the falls, we affixed our crampons, readied our ice axes and sorted out our gear. The most experienced member of the group led up the first pitch, placing (really, securing) ice screws as he went. It was a short and easy climb, with a rating of probably around WI 2+. The other member of our group followed on top-rope, carefully twirling out the ice screws as she went.
After she was up I followed. It was a great warm-up after almost two months of not being on the ice. When I reached the top, our senior ice climbing member had assembled a dizzyingly complex anchor mechanism involving an 10-inch-diameter ice column under a small ice chandelier, webbing attaching all three of us to it, and a means for belaying for the next pitch. With the help of the other two I attached myself to the frozen column, and couldn’t help but ponder its solidity while, still attached to it, I belayed our seasoned member as he set the next arrangement of ice screws above us.
Behold, the ice chandelier.
Actually, strictly speaking, around us would probably be a more accurate description. My other female companion and I had been busy chatting when a muffled shout came from above us to our right. This confused us because he had started on our left. Alas, he had started on the left side of the chandelier, traversed above it, and ended up fifteen feet to the right of it, where he set our next (and last) top-rope anchor of the day (it was already 3:00 in the afternoon). It dawned on me that the reason for this seemingly strange path was that there was no safe direct way to the bolted chains he was aiming for—no route he was comfortable leading, anyway.
So it was that my climb (as it was my turn to “clean” the screws) wasn’t going to be straight up—it was going to be up and across.
What this meant for my protection didn’t overly concern me until five minutes later, when in fact, I don’t believe anything has ever concerned me to such a degree.
As I made my way up the first fifteen feet of the smooth ice slope and raised my head to the first screw, I realized that for the first time since I’ve begun climbing, I was not top-roped, at least not in the strict sense. If I fell, it would be on what was above me, a four inch-long piece of metal winded into a sheet of frozen water. This anchor was no metal ring bored into solid rock, which had always been my climbing protection before. A pang of fear charged through me, but began to wane almost immediately. From what I’d heard, ice screws hold the vast majority of time. Besides, relying on ice screws made this real ice climbing. Which I was totally up for. This is what we’d come here for, right?
By the time I reached the next ice screw two minutes later, though, any morsel of comfort my reasoning had provided had evaporated into the still, cool air. To my right lay the last two ice screws, the line of protection directed almost precisely horizontally towards the bolted top-rope anchor forty feet to my right. A fall here would result in fairly substantial strain on the ice screw at hand. The way I saw it, the force from a rope pulled taught downwards whose origin is from the side just can’t be the ideal “falling” circumstance, if there ever was one.
View from the base of the falls.
Immediately I went to work on the screw in front of me, keen on reaching the top-rope anchor and thereby extracting myself from my dependence on the screws as soon as possible. But the awkward angle of balancing necessary for maneuvering the ice screw handle made the process more difficult than anticipated. The tautness of the rope was preventing me from by turns rotating the handle of the ice screw and unclipping its caribiner from the rope. Meanwhile, my fervent wish to keep my crampon points glued to the ice had yielded aching foot muscles, and the realization that what I was trying to do wasn’t working added a sick feeling of dread to the mix. I was stuck.
A minute of misery passed where I considered giving up, lowering off the ice screw back down to the safety of the ice column. But where would that leave us? Someone would have to clean the protection. And besides, the last thing I wanted to do was to test these things. I realized just how little I trusted ice screws. And that I had to do something, because just standing here, despondent and petrified and clutching my ice axes, wasn’t doing me any good.
There was only one way out of this very sour pickle I’d found myself in.
My thoughts and the irritating tune that had been repeating in my head for the last five minutes ebbed away, and in their place complete silence took over. For the first time that I can remember, I wasn’t thinking about anything. My mind went totally blank.
Then I acted. It was, truly, the very last word I wanted to utter at that moment, but it also happened to be the only way out of this funk.
“Slack!” I yelled.
“What?” someone called from down to my right.
“I need some slack!” I could hear the panicked desperation in my voice. I tried to dispel from my thoughts a mental scene of myself swinging down ten or fifteen feet, followed by each of the three ice screws popping out in orderly succession. It wasn’t working.
When the rope had loosened, I went to work on the screw. Thirty seconds, some teeth-gripping of the rope, and a bit of less-than-graceful body maneuvering later, the little bugger was mine.
By some stroke of luck, or karma, or a favorable word from the mountain gods, I mercifully touched down on solid snow again, ten minutes later.
“Sorry I took an age.” I said immediately, going about untying my figure eight knot. “You were probably bored to tears.”
One can only hope upon setting eyes on these items left by climbers past that the need to make use of them doesn’t present itself.
“Don’t worry about it.” I immediately christened my belayer as the most patient person in the world.
The truth of it, I told him, was that I had had a moment. Probably the most terrifying moment of my life, in fact. He just smiled. I couldn’t stop grinning.
In response to my incessant probing, our experienced member claimed repeatedly that the ice screws would have held in the event of a fall. He maintained his stance on the descent to the car, as well as on the drive back and later that night over drinks. But the temperature that day had been above freezing, and I wasn’t so sure.
Four nights later I dreamt that I was back on that frozen waterfall, in that same precarious spot. Curiosity had apparently gotten the better of me, and I set to punching the ice around all three ice screws to test their reliability (I tend to take greater climbing risks in the dream world because I am conscious of the knowledge that I can’t get hurt. It is convenient.).
Fractures cracked out from the first screw like lightning.
“Well, that one’s not gonna hold…”
I woke an indeterminate time later to a hollow thud and a searing burning in my knee, which I’d fortuitously slammed into the wall next to my bed mid-slumber.
While it still holds that I climbed a third of the way up a fourteener, in winter, in HIKING BOOTS.